Polite Dissent

Comics publisher EC took a substantial PR hit in the 1950s thanks in large part to psychiatrist Frederic Wertham’s book Seduction of the Innocent and anti-comic book congressional hearings. They gave up publishing their crime and horror comics, and instead switched to a “New Direction,” publishing comics designed to be more informative and inspirational. This concept never met with much success, and within a few years, the “New Direction” had failed and Mad Magazine was all that was left of a once successful comic book publisher.

M.D. was one of the “New Direction” comics. According to the preface of the first issue, M.D. was written to “contain stories of people…people who are helped by their Family Doctor and his associates in the Medical Profession. It will deal frankly and honestly with the diseases and misfortunes that beset people. It will deal graphically and candidly with the treatment they receive. At times, the stories will be poignant…at times they will be sad…at times they will be grim. But at all times, they will be true to life!”

Every issue of M.D. featured several realistic medical stories, each focused on a particular disease or condition. Issue #5 was the final issue of M.D. and frankly, it shows. The art is as intricate as always — if a little sensationalistic at times (particular when focusing on the grieving mother in the forefront of the panel, her fingers thrust worriedly at her lips) — but the stories are not nearly as compelling as in earlier issues, rather humdrum actually, which is unusual for any EC comic.

“Complete Cure” is the first story and tells of Philip Stuart, who had both of his legs amputated after an automobile accident. He takes the loss of his legs hard and decides to give up on his education and job, much to the concern of his wife and family doctor. In the end, Philip is introduced to another man who lost both of his legs (on the beaches of Normandy during D-Day, which pretty much trumps every other reason), but went on to become a successful surgeon. This inspires Philip who agrees to return to college.

The second story is “Child’s Play” and concerns Jimmy, a young child. He has gone deaf due to audiosclerosis (known as otosclerosis now) and needs an operation and a hearing aid to regain his hearing. His mother refuses, fearing that the other kids will make fun of Jimmy. Eventually, her husband steps in and sends Jimmy for the surgery. It’s a success and Jimmy’s hearing is returned. His mother still won’t let him play with his friends because she is convinced that they’ll reject him. One day she returns home from shopping and finds Jimmy missing. Fearfully, she runs down the street calling out his name, only to find him in the neighborhood clubhouse happily playing with the other kids, his hearing aid an object of interest, not scorn.

The third story, “Emergency” shows what happens in a hospital when a bad storm hits, knocking out both the power and emergency generators. By working tirelessly, the doctors are able to save everyone and even manage to perform an emergency surgery by flashlight. They end the story lamenting the fact that medicine has become so dependent on technology. Bear in mind that this was written over 50 years ago, and their medical technology consisted mostly of lights, x-ray machines, and iron lungs. The doctors of this story would be devastated to learn that modern medicine’s dependence on technology has increased a thousandfold since those halcyon days of not so long ago.

The fourth and final story deals with George Gordon. He is convinced that he has appendicitis, but his family doctor suspects otherwise. He believes that George has somatization disorder, and his depression is the root cause of George’s abdominal pain. George leaves in a huff and visits another doctor and hospital, but is told the same thing. Despondent, he threatens suicide but his family doctor is able to talk him down off the ledge and get him the help he needs. Based on my experience, somatization is never quite this easy to diagnose or treat, plus George seems to have as much a diagnosis of Munchausen’s Syndrome as somatization.

Previous posts on M.D.: Issue #1, Issue #2, Issue #3, and Issue #4.
Previous episodes of Flashback Week.