Polite Dissent

More exciting than the last episode, but the “big surprise” was obvious barely halfway in. Charlie is seriously creepy though.

The Plot: A small town in Pennsylvania has had seven people disappear in the past four months. Peter talks Agent Broyles into letting the Fringe Team investigate because he feels it may be related to Agent Dunham’s disappearance. Walter discovers a strange thick blue liquid at the scene of the latest disappearance, and Dunham realizes that one townsman, Andre Hughes, a retired doctor, was at the scene of several of the disappearances.

Peter and Dunham question Hughes at his home. Olivia thinks she hears someone else in the home, but can’t find anyone. She does find a fairly extensive lab in the house. They bring Hughes down to the Boston FBI office for questioning. He answers their questions, but refuses to give a blood sample. Dunham discovers that Hughes’s wife and infant son died in childbirth nearly twenty years before.

Suspecting foul play, the team exhumes the bodies of Hughes’s wife and son. The wife’s body is brought to Walter’s lab for evaluation but there is no body in the son’s coffin. It looks like something chewed its way in — or out. A small tunnel is found leading out of the grave into the ground.

Walter’s autopsy reveals that the late Mrs. Hughes had lupus, which he claims made it impossible for her to be pregnant. Closer examination reveals that she had been pregnant as there is still a placenta present; however, closer examination of the placenta reveals human DNA plus something else, apparently scorpion and mole rat DNA. Walter hypothesizes that Hughes used his knowledge of biology and genetics to alter his son while he was still in the womb — to make it more likely that he would survive the pregnancy.

Peter and Dunham suspect Hughes’s mutated son is still alive and living in tunnels under the town. They search Hughes’s house once again and find the partially decomposing corpse of a dog hidden behind a wall in the basement. They also find a recent tunnel with a dead — and gnawed — human body. Just as Dunham is telling Peter what she found, something grabs her from behind. Peter chases after her and there is a claustrophobic fight in an underground tunnel between Dunham, Peter, and Hughes’s mutated son. Peter stabs it through the chest. It tries to escape, only to be crushed by car that falls into the collapsing tunnel.

As the episode ends, Peter and Walter head of to go fishing, while Olivia meets with a mysterious man at a bowling alley who seems to know more than he is telling about the strange symptoms she’s been having since her trip to the other world.

1. A Quick Summation
This episode of Fringe = 65% The Lurking Fear + 30% Tremors+ 5% The Big Lebowski

2. A Silver Platter
Has then ever been an episode of Fringe telegraphed more blatantly? Who didn’t realize who the killer was, once Hughes mentioned that wife and infant son died in childbirth? The episode could have been salvaged by a climactic ending, but it instead it was over faster than the big boss fight in Transformers 2.

3. My Arm is Tingling Therefore I Cannot Move It
Walter seems to be confusing a paralytic with an anesthetic. Numbness is the sign of an anesthetic; not being able to move is a sign of a paralytic. I can numb your hand with lidocaine, but you’ll still be able to move it. On the other hand, I can paralyze you with pancuronium and you’ll be unable to move, but still feel everything.

4. Where’s House When You Need Him?
While lupus makes becoming pregnant — and carrying the child to term — very difficult, it does not make it impossible.
I’m impressed that Walter can find a malar rash on the skin of a corpse 17 years dead.

5. Dig Them Up
Since when do they open exhumed caskets in the open air, in public?
I would have like to see the search warrant/court order for the exhumation Exactly what information did they have on Hughes? An extremely vague note that may possibly if-you-squinted-your-eyes-right suggest he might have something to do with the death of his wife? He was seen near 3 of 7 missing persons? He, according to his constitutional rights, refused to give blood? He has a chemistry set?

6. String Him Up
That was a time consuming and elaborate way to hang yourself. Why not just use your shirt? What was that wire rack anyway?

Bad medicine, an unoriginal story, and another chimera as the bad guy all add up to the Doomsday clock moving one minute closer to midnight