Polite Dissent

A disappointing episode of Fringe. The writing was choppy and the science sloppy; it felt only half finished.

The Plot: Olivia wakes up at night with a bad migraine. She heads to a pharmacy to refill her prescription and on the way home she passes an all-night diner where Agent Lee is sitting; it seems he has bad insomnia since joining the Fringe Team.

Across town, a man is heading home late at night and has the strange sensation he is being followed. Just as he makes it to the front door of his apartment building he is attacked. When the police arrive a few minutes later, they find him dead, and white as a sheet – drained of all pigment. Unsurprisingly, the Fringe Team is called in. Walter suggests the victim may have been scared to deat,h and Agent Lee finds blood on some broken glass, evidence of their mystery suspect. The blood is identified as belonging to an infant who died 22 years ago. Visiting the hospital where the baby was born, the team learns the baby had an unknown genetic condition, and didn’t really die, but instead was kidnapped by a company known as Cyprox, an old subsidiary of Massive Dynamic. Olivia visits Nina Sharp who admits Cyprox performed genetic experimentation on Eugene (what the baby was named), but insists the experimentation saved his life. He disappeared after a lab fire ten years before and they had assumed he died.

Meanwhile, another body has been found at another apartment complex. The building is locked down and the lights shut off. Walter has determined that Eugene can be seen under ultraviolet light and so groups of FBI agents search the building with UV lights and dogs. Olivia falls in a hole and Eugene rescues her, but then runs off. The team continues to search the building, but calls it off after there is no more sign of Eugene. They do find his hidden apartment and lab in the basement. Olivia speculates that Eugene just wants to be seen. A short time later, Eugene, now looking normal, enters the elevator at the apartment complex and has a short conversation with Julie, the object of his infatuation. As she leaves the elevator and the doors close, Eugene collapses to the floor, twitches, and dies.

Later that night, Olivia is getting ready to head out to the all-night diner to meet up with Agent Lee when she is knocked out by a gas pumped into her apartment. Two men enter her apartment, disable the security cameras, and inject her with a red medication. They mention that she’ll be out for a couple of hours, and wake with a massive headache. As they leave the room, we see Nina Sharp standing by, supervising the entire operation.

1. Not Quite Thirty Minutes Or Less
It takes more than 4 days to get genetic testing done, especially if so many “experts” are involved.

2. Let’s Digitize The Tests We Didn’t Perform
I realize this may or may-not or may-sometimes be our universe, but hospitals don’t keep DNA databases. And even if they did, why would it be online when the episode made the point of explicitly mentioning that all the hospital records from that era were on paper?

3. It’s A Hard Knock Life
Did Baby Boy Bryant didn’t have any parents? (The name is what you’d expect in a hospital file; all newborns are “baby-boy-mothers-lastname” or “baby-girl-mothers-lastname”).

4. Sorry Jean Valjean
A person’s hair turning white from a sudden fright is a myth. At most, theoretically, you could change the color of any hair that is newly growing, but the color of hair that’s already emerged from the follicles cannot be changed (excluding Clairol and Just for Men, of course).
What exactly was the pigment drained through? The pores? Capillaries? What?
More importantly, if Eugene is pigmentless, how does he see? The retinas require pigment to function.

5. Unclear On the Concept
I’m unclear how Eugene stealing other people’s pigment was returning himself to his original condition, since he was born without any pigment.

6. Ennui
In this entire episode, the Fringe Team accomplished nothing. Seriously: if they had not become involved, Eugene would have talked to Julie and died, just like he did after they became involved. They saved no lives; they prevented no crimes. There’s nothing quite like watching the characters of a TV show so completely not matter.

7. Mischief Managed
No octopus or chameleon can mimic that complicated an environment. They “blend in”, they don’t disappear. It’s camouflage, not the One Ring.

8. Spotting Scorpions
Why not bring in decent sized UV lights rather than those dinky little flashlight ones? It would be very easy to miss someone with one of those, especially the way they were haphazardly swinging them around. The ones we use in our office are easily four times the size of those, light, and portable.

The plot was too sloppy, let alone the science, for this to be considered a good episode, let alone the advertised mid-season finale. The Fringe Doomsday Clock gains two minutes to midnight.

Tags: television fringe time pigment ultraviolet