Hawk and Dove #4 is another issue where the majority of the story is just people sitting around talking; there is little actual action. There’s nothing wrong with that, per se, except that it’s clearly not one of Liefeld’s strengths. It also means that two of the four issues have been primarily conversation instead of action (I know last issue I complained about it being an issue-long fight scene. I’m not being contradictory: I think good comics require a solid mix of both action and non-action scenes; not one or the other).
After collaring Condor last issue, Hawk and Dove are questioning him at the local police station. Despite various threats from Hawk, Condor is refusing to talk.
Meanwhile, Dove thinks back to her fight last issue with Swan. You remember that fight, right? It’s the one we didn’t get to see. Well now, an issue after the fact, we finally learned what happened. During the tussle, Dove zaps Swan with beams of light shot from her hands and then starts really pounding her, all the while telling Swan about how hard she’s had it in life. Swan manages to cut Dove with her sword, but then mysteriously vanishes when struck by the light released from the wound.
Now, suddenly, Condor agrees to talk. He reveals that he is two hundred years old and he drops some comments about the “War Circle” and how its numbers are finally getting low. He expects Hawk to be aware of the Circle and seems amused when he isn’t. He informs Hawk that he plans to cut out and eat his avatar and casually mentions that he wants to kill Dove simply because he’s not sure what she is. He ends by telling the team that Dove’s association with Deadman makes them easy to track.
Conveniently, Deadman shows up, and Condor shares an important fact: Swan didn’t die, but instead became immaterial, just like Deadman. Right on cue, Swan shows up, grabs, and subdues Deadman. At the same time, a helicopter arrives outside the police station and a squad of evil scientist/anarchist Quirk’s zombie-men show up and bust Condor out. In the ensuing melee, Hawk is knocked unconscious from a shot to the back and Dove is left alone fighting the zombies.
Liefeld’s art, by itself, is no worse than it was last issue. There’s the same bizarre posing, mismatching planes, and missing backgrounds I’ve come to expect. What is worse this time is the panel-to-panel continuity. Here’s two quick examples: first, the fit of Dove’s mask changes frequently, from sitting at her hairline, to crossing the middle of the forehead, to everything in between — and this changes from panel to panel on the same page. A second example: when first shown, Condor is wearing heavy manacles, then a page later, he has normal handcuffs on, then toward the end of the issue, he’s shown with his arms strapped to the chair.
On a scale of 1 to 5 deformed Captain Americas, with 1 being good and 5 being execrable, this art on this issue rates 4 deformed Captain Americas.




Light beams from the hands? Those are new powers for Dove. as for her injury, light has come from her wounds when she was cut previously (in the later issues of the last Hawk and Dove series), but never like this.
There seems to be a new backstory for Dawn. “Fighting other people to eat,” and “dealing with scum.” It will be interesting to see where this goes.
The covers aren’t working. The posing, even on the fight scene covers, is uninteresting and the colors seem flat.
Stop with the “Kaaia!” please.
Would Judge Hall really pull strings to allow Hawk and Dove to question Condor. That is very unlike the pre-nu52 Judge Hall, who was a strict follower of the rule of law and fairly anti-vigilante. And how much pull would a federal judge really have at the level of a local police department, or even the SCU?
Condor and Swan have a point: why is Dove being so aggressive and physical?
My main problem with this issue, and the Hawk and Dove reboot overall, is that they’re not very heroic. I don’t necessarily need my heroes to always win, but I want them to at least be competent — to act like heroes — and I’m not seeing that here. I know that being a super-hero is clasically all about reacting: the villains enact a plot and the heroes react. But that’s not what’s happening. Certainly Hawk and Dove have been taking the fight to Quirk, but it was always clear he wasn’t the major villain, Condor was. And against Condor they’ve accomplished nothing. They’re been led along like lambs to the slaughter and they seem none the wiser. Everything we’ve learned comes from infodumps from the villains; the heroes haven’t learned anything on their own — they’re just flailing at shadows. This is frustrating to read in any comic, but especially in a comic I had such high hopes for.
All Previous Hawk and Dove Reviews